Reviewing site statistics, I have always been struck by the fact
that the so-called 'DIY' Induction of Labour is always up there
in the top 5 most searched terms on our Pregnancy and Childbirth
information website.
As a practising obstetrician, however, I am never
surprised by this. In my day to day work I am all the time encountering
women at term who are otherwise well but who, after 40 odd weeks
of pregnancy, just cannot wait for it to be over and done with.
They are physically and emotionally drained and would happily swap
that stress with the stress of looking after a fragile newborn.
It is an accepted medical scientific fact that by
37 weeks of gestation, a baby in the womb is technically at term
and therefore functionally mature and able to cope with the outside
world. That is true for the overwhelming majority. However, spontaneous
labour may not occur for another three or four weeks, even more.
For some, that is sometimes too much to cope with. It is therefore
no surprise that these women clamour for labour induction.
There is almost total consensus among obstetricians
and midwives that induction of labour before at least 41 weeks in
the absence of a medical indication (fetal or maternal wellbeing)
is not a good idea. This is for a number of quite valid and powerful
reasons which are not the focus of this article.
So, what is the truth regarding do-it-yourself induction
of labour at term? Is there a scientifically proven 'DIY' method
that works?
METHODS:
* Spicy Food: This is stuff of folklore. There is
belief that a food that is highly spicy will soon get labour going.
Clearly this is based on the hypothesis that the uterus alongside
every other part will be stimulated into contractions. Many might
have achieved the 'runs' with this strategy but there is simply
no evidence that it is an effective 'natural' induction agent.
* Acupuncture: There are a lot of claims on the
effectiveness of acupuncture for induction of labour. However, this
is bedevilled by the fact that the specific acupuncture technique
is not standardised, the service is not properly regulated and availability
is patchy in many places. This means it is difficult to evaluate
and a Cochrane Review of studies on the method published in 2001
concluded that they were all poorly designed and therefore this
remains unproven.
* Sexual Intercourse is another popular method that
I have personally recommended to couples. Like many colleagues,
I have done this partially because it is certainly harmless, may
relieve some of the stress and, who knows, it might work! The logic
behind this recommendation is the probability of facilitating a
release of enough prostaglandins and oxytocin to get labour going.
Prostaglandins are the natural chemicals that trigger labour onset
and oxytocin is responsible for uterine contractions. Penetrative
sex does stimulate prostaglandin release from the neck of the womb
(cervix) and semen released into the birth canal contains prostaglandins.
In addition, if the breast nipples are stimulated, oxytocin is released
from the pituitary gland in the brain. So, the theoretical basis
appears solid but actual scientific evidence that this works remains
weak.
* Castor Oil: Ingesting this is claimed to stimulate
the uterus lead to labour onset. Whilst this claim has been around
for decades, there is actually no evidence that it works. Moreover,
it can cause nausea, vomiting or even diarrhoea, not an attractive
prospect for one heavily pregnant at the end of her tether.
* Reflexology: This suffers from the same weakness
as acupuncture. Put simply, evidence of effectiveness in induction
of labour is lacking.
* Zero balancing: In the US and Australia, alternative
therapists offer 'Zero balancing'. This is described as a "hands-on
method of balancing body energy with body structure that integrates
a Western anatomical view of structure with Eastern concepts into
a Zero Balancing protocol". This, strictly speaking, is meant
to combat stress and therefore minimize the need for induction of
labour.
* Hot baths: They may be good at relieving stress
but there is certainly no evidence that they can help trigger labour
onset.
* Herbal preparations: Many herbal preparations
have been claimed to accelerate labour onset. These include evening
primrose oil, red raspberry leaves extract, black cohosh etc. None
of these have evidence to back up the claims. There is also the
added concern that potential risks, dosage and drug interaction
properties are not known.
In summary, whilst the concept of 'DIY' Induction
of Labour may be attractive, reasonable and in the right conditions,
harmless, there is no real proven effective method out there today
that a woman can employ with confidence. It also remains true that
even with the proven pharmacological induction methods that doctors
use, if the cervix is assessed to be unfavourable, the risk of failure
may be unacceptably high.